Wednesday, November 6, 2013

Making People Pay - A Book Review

It is ironic that I should be reviewing a book of Taxation, considering that I shut down my consultancy merely because I was putting in more effort in computing and paying various taxes than I had to put in to earn the money. I have always considered it funny that this is one area where you need to put in a lot of learning and effort as well as seek expert advice in order to pay out money when, in any other realm of Society, the one who puts in the effort gets paid!

The author - Dr. Sibichen Mathew - is an IRS officer with a stellar academic background in Sociology, Public Policy and taxation. This book amply reflects his deep knowledge of his varied academic interests.

Dr. Mathew’s book “Making People Pay” aims to identify the reasons for tax evasion – specifically Income tax – and the means by which people can be enthused to be tax-compliant. In the process, he gives a glimpse of the global and Indian history of taxation peppered with various interesting anecdotes; the rationale and purpose for taxation – including the ones that, in the past, caused taxes to be labelled immoral at times and the reasons for lack of tax compliance. He also suggests the means whereby tax compliance may be improved and identifies some of the challenges posed by globalization to the taxation arms of governments.

What is specifically interesting in the book is the detailing of the genesis of tax evasion. The author does not rest merely with assuming evasion to be an outcome of a lack of integrity. He has applied his mind and effort on the various economic, sociological, psychological and procedural aspects that could lead to tax-evasive behavior and attempted an exhaustive set of studies to identify the causal factors.

The book is an outcome of studies conducted by the author and the details of the studies and conclusions are outlined in Chapters 6 and 7. All the preceding chapters can be understood by the lay reader – and the easy narrative style and interesting anecdotes will keep the reader interested. The chapters related to the study, however, do read like a report and, though they contain interesting insights into the mind of the tax-payer, they may prove to be a ..err..taxing read! If I may suggest something to the author it would be to re-write these chapters – the insights derived from the studies - in the same easy narrative style of the others and leave the details of the study to appendices.

Even with that minor glitch, the book is still not too taxing a read overall and gives insights into both the functioning of the Income Tax department and the causal factors of tax non-compliance. Anyone who is interested in the functioning of the world we live in will certainly find benefit in the book.

Details of the book can be seen here

(Disclaimer: The author, Dr. Sibichen Mathew, is a fellow-blogger and a friend)

10 comments:

  1. All the best to Sibi for the new book! The title is really catchy, I must say.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Very catchy and the book is a decent read for all that it is about taxes :)

      Delete
  2. A book on taxation that 'is still not too taxing a read'... will recommend it to my wife as she is the one who manages these things at home. Loved the easy expression in the review.

    Arvind Passey
    www.passey.info

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This one, Arvind, is more about why people evade taxes than about how to pay your own :)

      Delete
  3. As usual, aligns more or less with my impression of the book.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The insistence of the government that the tax forms be complicated and not easily understood by the common man could also be a cause for evasion. At one time a single page return was introduced only to be reverted back to the cumbersome format.
    Even in a book review we could see the 'Suresh' touch!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hahaha! You will soon have me believe that there is something called a "Suresh" touch :)

      Delete
  5. You piqued my interest. Will keep an eye out for it. And I completely agree with Rajeev Moothedath about how it is necessary to make the process of filing returns a simpler one.

    Here in Canada, I have always filed my returns on my own and online. If you have all your docs ready and organized, a couple of hours should do it.

    ReplyDelete